Poise and promise stand out after Trey Yesavage’s MLB debut

by | Sep 17, 2025

The discussion about where Trey Yesavage goes from his Major League Baseball debut with the Toronto Blue Jays has been more than positive.

He struck out a team-record nine batters, the most by a pitcher in his MLB debut, and was dominant after giving up a first-inning run. While he didn’t factor in the decision, he did make a big impact in more ways than one.

What impact he makes for the Toronto Blue Jays now is being debated. He has gone from a possible reliever out of the bullpen in the postseason to a continued starter through the postseason. Athlon Sports’ Kristie Ackert approached that topic in her latest piece.

She writes in part, “Former big leaguer Mark DeRosa, and USA Team manager for the World Baseball Classic,  said on MLB Network he expects Toronto will stick with their veteran starters for the playoffs. They will stick with Max Scherzer, Chris Bassitt, Shane Bieber, or Kevin Gausman.

“Yesavage, despite his tremendous debut, may get limited or relief exposure rather than a full run as a starter in October. An AL scout suggested Tuesday that Yesavage could be devastatingly effective out of the bullpen in the playoffs. It’s fewer innings, high leverage, and virtually no tape on him could make him tougher than a lot of polished starters.”

Click here to read more.

Keegan Matheson, who covers the Blue Jays for MLB.com, spoke with Yesavage’s newest teammate, Kevin Gausman, about what he saw. Gausman, also a starting pitcher, was left amazed by Yesavage’s performance and thinks the sky is the limit for him.

“Any vice you have is going to be magnified,” Gausman said to Matheson. “[Yesavage] seems like a guy you’re never really going to have to worry about. He’s only been here a couple of days and I’ve only talked to him a couple of times, but he just seems way older than 22. Me at 22 and him at 22? Big, big difference.”

Click here to read more of that story.

Photo credit: Trey Yesavage, right (AP photo)

Check out Pirate Radio

Download our mobile app now!

Website | Facebook | X (formerly Twitter) | Instagram | YouTube | Apple Podcasts | Spotify

Top Headlines

PRL Monday: Fallout from ECU-UTSA, march to Final Four and more

A new sports week is here and there’s a lot to talk about on today’s show. We’ll have Brandon Golden on to discuss ECU baseball and its weekend series with UTSA. We'll also talk about where the team is so far and the week ahead. We'll also discuss the men's basketball...

Pirates fall short in extra innings against UTSA

The ECU baseball team dropped a 9-8 decision to UTSA on Sunday to drop the American Conference series, its first of the season. Check out Pirate Radio Download our mobile app now! Website | Facebook | X (formerly Twitter) | Instagram | YouTube | Apple Podcasts |...

Pirates fall to UTSA to split series, Game 3 on Sunday

UTSA eened the series with ECU with a 6-1 victory on Saturday. The two teams will finish out the series on Sunday. Check out Pirate Radio Download our mobile app now! Website | Facebook | X (formerly Twitter) | Instagram | YouTube | Apple Podcasts | Spotify =====...

ECU’s Norby throws immaculate inning in shutout against UTSA

ECU's Ethan Norby had an immaculate inning, throwing nine pitches that resulted in strikes in Friday's win over UTSA. Ethan Norby with the immaculate inning 🤟🏼🏴‍☠️ https://t.co/oZEAEMhrXA pic.twitter.com/Fx99YwM0qc — ECU Baseball (@ECUBaseball) March 28, 2026 Check...

Photos: Pirate Radio Luncheon with Jay Glazer

We've added photo galleries of photos taken during Jay Glazer's appearance at the Pirate Radio Luncheon on March 23, 2026. Click here to see photos from Glazer's appearance at the ECU-UAB game on March 22, which also included him throwing out the first pitch. Click...

Duke rallies in ninth inning to beat ECU

Duke rallied for five runs in the final three innings, including a ninth-inning walk-off home run to beat ECU, 9-8 on Tuesday. Check out Pirate Radio Download our mobile app now! Website | Facebook | X (formerly Twitter) | Instagram | YouTube | Apple Podcasts |...

PRL Wednesday: Baseball, baseball and more baseball

The start of the Major League Baseball season is here, so there’s even more baseball to discuss on Wednesday's show. We’ll discuss the fallout from Tuesday’s loss by ECU to Duke. We’ll continue the baseball conversation with Mark Brown, who will preview the upcoming...

The Brandon Golden Show: ECU baseball coach Cliff Godwin

The latest edition of "The Brandon Golden Show" features one of his former co-workers. ECU baseball coach Cliff Godwin joins the show to catch up and to talk about the Pirates. They'll cover the season's happenings so far, American Conference play and what lies ahead...