Poise and promise stand out after Trey Yesavage’s MLB debut

by | Sep 17, 2025

The discussion about where Trey Yesavage goes from his Major League Baseball debut with the Toronto Blue Jays has been more than positive.

He struck out a team-record nine batters, the most by a pitcher in his MLB debut, and was dominant after giving up a first-inning run. While he didn’t factor in the decision, he did make a big impact in more ways than one.

What impact he makes for the Toronto Blue Jays now is being debated. He has gone from a possible reliever out of the bullpen in the postseason to a continued starter through the postseason. Athlon Sports’ Kristie Ackert approached that topic in her latest piece.

She writes in part, “Former big leaguer Mark DeRosa, and USA Team manager for the World Baseball Classic,  said on MLB Network he expects Toronto will stick with their veteran starters for the playoffs. They will stick with Max Scherzer, Chris Bassitt, Shane Bieber, or Kevin Gausman.

“Yesavage, despite his tremendous debut, may get limited or relief exposure rather than a full run as a starter in October. An AL scout suggested Tuesday that Yesavage could be devastatingly effective out of the bullpen in the playoffs. It’s fewer innings, high leverage, and virtually no tape on him could make him tougher than a lot of polished starters.”

Click here to read more.

Keegan Matheson, who covers the Blue Jays for MLB.com, spoke with Yesavage’s newest teammate, Kevin Gausman, about what he saw. Gausman, also a starting pitcher, was left amazed by Yesavage’s performance and thinks the sky is the limit for him.

“Any vice you have is going to be magnified,” Gausman said to Matheson. “[Yesavage] seems like a guy you’re never really going to have to worry about. He’s only been here a couple of days and I’ve only talked to him a couple of times, but he just seems way older than 22. Me at 22 and him at 22? Big, big difference.”

Click here to read more of that story.

Photo credit: Trey Yesavage, right (AP photo)

Check out Pirate Radio

Download our mobile app now!

Website | Facebook | X (formerly Twitter) | Instagram | YouTube | Apple Podcasts | Spotify

Top Headlines

Podcast: Voice of BYU Greg Wrubell

PIRATE RADIO PODCAST - The voice of BYU, Greg Wrubell, was part of Tuesday’s show and talked about Saturday’s big game with ECU. Click one of the links below to hear the conversation. 📺 YouTube 🍎 Apple Podcasts ✳️ Spotify Check out Pirate Radio Download our mobile app...

The Holton Ahlers Show: Previewing BYU vs. ECU

The latest edition of "The Holton Ahlers Show" gives Holton and Caiden Norman the chance to preview Saturday's BYU game. They are also joined by former ECU football player Jack Powers, who has been part of the show as a co-host before. The three break down the game...

Jerry Jones: Shavon Revel on track to return after NFL designation

Take heart, Cowboys fans. Help is on the way. The Dallas Cowboys’ defense has been atrocious in the first two weeks of the NFL season. They are really lucky to be 1-1 because the Giants are so bad. #DallasCowboys owner and GM Jerry Jones tells @1053SS, @rjchoppy and...

Tyler Snead inks two-year contract extension with CFL’s Alouettes

Tyler Snead’s best season in the CFL is being recognized by his team. The Montreal Alouettes have extended the contract of the ECU football alum for two more years, according to multiple sources. CFL.ca reports the contract keeps Snead there through the 2027 season....

Could ECU game be last for BYU coach?

BYU football coach Kalani Sitake has his alma mater heading to Greenville as the odds-on favorite against ECU on Saturday. Odds are he could be the next football coach at UCLA, at least according to ESPN. UCLA fired DeShaun Foster as its coach on Sunday following a...

The Brian Bailey Show: Previewing Saturday’s ECU-BYU game

Tuesday's edition of "The Brian Bailey Show" has a full take on this Saturday's big game. BYU comes to town to face ECU for a 7:30 p.m. ESPN2 game at Dowdy-Ficklen Stadium. Bailey gets you ready for the game with a big lineup of guests: 🏴‍☠️🏈 Today at Noon on the...

Trey Yesavage sparkles in MLB debut for Blue Jays, makes history

It was a Monday night Trey Yesavage won't soon forget. Neither will his family. A HISTORIC debut 👏 #lightsupletsgo pic.twitter.com/5hzJzAK8qC — Toronto Blue Jays (@BlueJays) September 16, 2025 After giving up a run in the first inning, the ECU baseball alum went to...

Video: Pirates’ Harrell, Wright, Brown speak along with BYU’s

Monday began a new week for the ECU football team as preps were underway for this Saturday's big home game with BYU. Coach Blake Harrell met with the media along with quarterback Mike Wright Jr. and cornerback TyMir Brown. Also on Monday, BYU held its press conference...

What plans to Blue Jays have for Trey Yesavage after Monday?

ECU baseball alum Trey Yesavage will make his Major League Baseball debut Monday when he pitches at the Tampa Bay Rays. Then what? The Blue Jays have a pretty solid starting rotation with Kevin Gausman, Shane Bieber, Max Scherzer, Jose Berrios and Chris Bassitt. While...