Around the Foghorn: Here’s why it’s a good idea to keep Carson Whisenhunt on Giants’ roster

by | Aug 6, 2025

After two quality starts for the San Francisco Giants, you would think it’s a no-brainer that ECU alum Carson Whisenhunt stays on the roster.

But it’s apparently not that easy.

AroundtheFogHorn.com’s Jeff Young wrote about why keeping Whisenhunt on the roster through the rest of the season is crucial. A no-decision against the Pirates and a win over the Mets were big for a team struggling with injuries to its starting pitching and the less-than-stellar outings by veteran Justin Verlander.

The main reason to keep him, Young writes, is due to Whisenhunt being eligible for the Rule 5 draft this winter. The Giants knew that they were going to protect him from that by adding him to the 40-man roster. Being added to the team was another step and, if he makes the expanded roster, it will all become a moot point.

Young writes in part, “The Giants now need to be careful with this decision. They do not want to promote him and then send him back down, thereby potentially burning a minor league option year this late in the season. That would be a waste, but it is something they have done recently with Wade Meckler.

An option year is used when a player spends at least 20 days in the minors on an optional assignment. This does not include a rehab assignment. A player does not immediately lose an option year when he is optioned. That point is often confusing.”

Click here to read more.

Photo credit: Carson Whisenhunt (Ishika Samant, Getty Images)

Check out Pirate Radio

Website | Facebook | X (formerly Twitter) | Instagram | YouTube | Apple Podcasts | Spotify

Top Headlines

Photos: Pirate Radio Luncheon with Jay Glazer

We've added photo galleries of photos taken during Jay Glazer's appearance at the Pirate Radio Luncheon on March 23, 2026. Click here to see photos from Glazer's appearance at the ECU-UAB game on March 22, which also included him throwing out the first pitch. Click...

Duke rallies in ninth inning to beat ECU

Duke rallied for five runs in the final three innings, including a ninth-inning walk-off home run to beat ECU, 9-8 on Tuesday. Check out Pirate Radio Download our mobile app now! Website | Facebook | X (formerly Twitter) | Instagram | YouTube | Apple Podcasts |...

PRL Wednesday: Baseball, baseball and more baseball

The start of the Major League Baseball season is here, so there’s even more baseball to discuss on Wednesday's show. We’ll discuss the fallout from Tuesday’s loss by ECU to Duke. We’ll continue the baseball conversation with Mark Brown, who will preview the upcoming...

The Brandon Golden Show: ECU baseball coach Cliff Godwin

The latest edition of "The Brandon Golden Show" features one of his former co-workers. ECU baseball coach Cliff Godwin joins the show to catch up and to talk about the Pirates. They'll cover the season's happenings so far, American Conference play and what lies ahead...

The Brian Bailey Show: Second chance at the NCAA Tournament

Tuesday's edition of The Brian Bailey Show takes another crack at the NCAA Tournament. If your bracket is already busted, Bailey's show can help with that. He'll conduct his latest "Second Chance with the Sweet 16." There will be discussion about the games and a...

Pirates lose series finale to UAB

East Carolina wrapped up its American Conference series with UAB with an 11-4 loss on Sunday. Check out Pirate Radio Download our mobile app now! Website | Facebook | X (formerly Twitter) | Instagram | YouTube | Apple Podcasts | Spotify ===== Photo credit: (ECU Sports...